Supreme Court ‘Disturbed’ By Central Pollution Control Board For Not Studying Impact Of Fire Crackers

The Supreme Court today took the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to task for not  conducting any study on the harmful effects of materials used in the manufacture of fire crackers despite its directions, saying it was “really disturbed”. The apex court termed as “astonishing” that the board has not conducted a study or prepared a report on this aspect and said that government authorities have paid “very little or no attention” to the possible health hazards faced by children due to exposure to such chemicals. It said these authorities need to realise their responsibility regarding the care and protection of health of the people in Delhi and the national capital region (NCR) and the importance of launching a sustained campaign to reduce air pollution to manageable limits during and after Diwali.

Also Read: For A Clean And Green Air, Scientists Create Fuel From Methane Using Oxygen

“What has really disturbed us is that the CPCB was directed on November 11, 2016 to study and prepare a report within three months on the harmful effects of the materials used in the manufacture of fireworks. “It is astonishing that the CPCB has not conducted the study and prepared a report as directed,” a bench comprising Justices Madan B Lokur and Deepak Gupta said, adding “the right to breathe clean air is a recognised right under our Constitution”.

The top court, which temporarily lifted its earlier order suspending permanent licences for sale of fire crackers in the NCR, said no standards have been laid down by the CPCB which could give any indication of acceptable and permissible limit of constituent metals or chemicals used in fire crackers and released in air, beyond which their presence would be harmful.

“What is also worrying, apart from the absence of standards or limits having been laid down by the CPCB, is that very little or no attention seems to have been paid by any of the governmental authorities to the possible health hazards faced by children due to exposure to chemicals in fireworks,” the bench said.

Also Read: Delhi’s Foul Air If Cleaned Up, City Residents Could Gain Nine Years In Their Average Life Span: Study

“The governmental authorities need to realise their responsibility regarding the care and protection of the health of the people in Delhi and NCR and the importance of launching a sustained campaign to reduce air pollution to manageable limits during Diwali and the period immediately thereafter.

The health of children should be of foremost concern in this regard,” it said. The bench also observed that presence of certain metals or chemicals in the air beyond a particular limit would be inadvisable, but that limit is not known to anybody including the CPCB.

“Therefore, any discussion on the subject of whether there is an excessive presence of a particular chemical in the air will not yield any result unless some authority lays down an acceptable standard of what is excessive and what is not,” it said.

While temporarily lifting its earlier order, the top court said continuing the suspension of licences “might be too radical a step to take for the present” and a graded and balanced approach was needed to reduce and gradually eliminate air pollution in Delhi-NCR caused by bursting of fireworks.

“At the same time it is necessary to ensure that injustice is not caused to those who have already been granted a valid permanent licence to possess and sell fireworks in Delhi and the NCR. The graded and balanced approach is not intended to dilute our primary concern which is and remains the health of everybody and the human right to breathe good quality air or at least not be compelled to breathe poor quality air,” the court said.

It said the health of people in Delhi-NCR must take precedence over any commercial or other interest of the fire crackers manufacturers and a graded regulation was needed which would eventually result in prohibition. It observed that large numbers of temporary licences were issued for possession and sale of fireworks in Delhi-NCR and there was a need to regulate the availability and sale of fire crackers here. The apex court’s order came on the application filed by manufacturers and suppliers of fire crackers, primarily based in Sivakasi in Tamil Nadu, seeking relaxation of its earlier order.