New Delhi: In an ambitious move to make India free from waste by October 2, 2019, the government had launched a massive waste management project in 4,000 cities across the country on June 5, 2017, on the World Environment Day. The project launched a nation-wide guideline for waste segregation, wherein individuals need to follow a 2-bin system and segregate their waste at source. The state governments and municipal corporations distributed two separate bins to everyone – blue dustbin for dry waste and green dustbin for wet waste. Nearly two years down the line the on-ground reality in major cities of India, such as the national capital region of Delhi, indicates that waste segregation is yet to take off and so a dream of a Clean India where waste is scientifically handled, remains a difficult one to achieve by October 2, 2019.
For a ground reality check of waste management measures adopted in New Delhi, the NDTV team undertook a day’s field trip to one of South Delhi’s most busy locations – Sarai Kale Khan.
The area is always crowded, with the constant flow of people and traffic. Apart from residents and commuters flocking the area, the 10 kilometres radius of Sarai Kale Khan area also has 50 shelters built by the Delhi Government for the homeless.
Each of these centres has on an average 50-60 people residing. The walls of shelters are painted with dim grey and black colour messages like ‘Swachh Bharat, Swachh Delhi,’ ‘Open Urination and Open Defecation are prohibited’, ‘Keep The Area Clean’ and so on, but reality overlooking these walls is contrary to these messages. Ironically, right next to these swachh messages, one can find piles of garbage, with millions of flies hovering over the dumps. The air around these shelter homes is heavy with the stench of urine, making the problem of open urination in the area evident. Some of the mobile toilets that have been installed are dysfunctional, while some are too dirty to use. Apart from open defecation, the other worrisome part is the fact that thousands of people living here simply dump their waste in their surroundings, without any semblance or idea about proper waste management.
Waste Management Or Lack Of It In Government Constructed Shelters For Homeless
NDTV visited some of these shelters for the homeless to speak to the locals and know how they are imbibing the objectives and contributing to India’s biggest cleanliness movement – Swachh Bharat Abhiyan. 26-year-old Chameli told us for her Swachh Bharat Abhiyan is access to toilets alone, when asked about waste management she said,
Kachre ka kya hai, jab aaya tab hi hummnein peeche pheka (Garbage is not a problem, whenever we generate it we dispose it of by throwing it in our backyard.
On the other hand, 36-year-old Shanti, who has been living in the shelter from the past 3 three years said,
In the name of Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, the authorities have only given us the access of these mobile toilets. No one ever taught us where we all should be disposing of our waste. There are no dustbins here, nor has any sanitation worker been allocated in these areas who can come and collect the waste. Since we have no options, we simply throw the garbage in the backyard.
Mahesh who has been living in the shelter home for men from past 6 six months added,
I have come to this shelter home recently, the corner I have been given is near a big window from where one can get to see all the greenery and some parts of the Yamuna that is flowing near the DND (Delhi-Noida-Delhi) highway. But the problem is that the area behind the shelter home is filled with piles of garbage and is always stinking. When I came to this shelter home, the pile was one inch tall and now it is almost at the height of my window which is at 3 a height of three feet from the ground
He further added,
The problem is that the garbage stinks a lot, sometimes, I wake up to this smell, while sometimes, I fall asleep with this mess. Because of the stink, I prefer staying outside on the roads.
Sarai Kale Khan Field Trip Findings: Why Is Garbage Piling Up?
None of the people in the shelters built by the government have been given any training on how to manage their waste nor any shelter homes are equipped with proper waste collection and disposal facilities, as a result, the people living in these homes have found a short cut to get rid of their waste throwing the waste behind the shelter homes.
So all the shelter homes have their backyards filled with all sorts of waste that emanate revolting stench and make the surroundings unhealthy.
Sarai Kale Khan Field Trip Findings: Garbage Pile Up, No End In Sight
The caretaker of one of the shelter homes noted, ‘It is like Versova Beach when there was no clean-up happening. ’ Explaining the problem, Suresh Chourasiya, who has been taking care of the shelter home from past three years said,
The problem is that Swachh Bharat Abhiyan is limited to the societies and colonies of Delhi. The municipal corporation or the government has never come to these shelter homes and guided the homeless on how they can contribute towards the nation’s biggest movement – Swachh Bharat Abhiyan. These people understand the meaning of living in clean surroundings, but the problem is that they have no facilities.
NDTV also spoke to Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board (DUSIB), the authority that has made these shelter homes under Delhi Government in the Sarai Kale Khan area, a senior official who wished to remain anonymous said,
When we were asked to make these shelters by the Delhi government, we were simply been asked to provide home-stay facilities and toilets. So, we made the arrangements accordingly. Currently, nothing has been told to us for waste management facilities.
NDTV also asked the official whether the people were given adequate training on keeping the toilets and the shelters clean, the official said,
When we make these facilities, we hand it over to caretakers, it then becomes his/her duty to take care of the property.
Suraj Prasad, caretaker of one of the family shelters adds,
Yes, we do ask people to clean the toilets after they have used it. But, nothing on the garbage we have ever told these people because it is Municipal Corporation’s job. Till today, there are no waste management facilities here, these people end up throwing the garbage in the backyard only. In fact, no one has ever come to these shelters and has checked on how people living here are managing waste.
Why Waste Segregation Has Not Taken Off Despite Municipal Corporation Spending Crores On Bins
Sarai Kale Khan falls under the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC). According to the South Delhi Municipal Corporation, from the time waste segregation rule came into effect in 2017, Rs 7.7 crore has been spent on the installation of twin-coloured bins (Blue bin for dry waste and a green bin for wet waste). But so far the impact of this effort is not visible in areas like Sarai Kale Khan. On NDTV’s visit to the nearby kachra (garbage) centre of Sarai Kale Khan area, we spotted huge green bins that were filled with the mixed waste. On the other hand, the sanitation workers who are going door to door for garbage collection have no bins for collection, the waste is being collected in a small cycle cart, with no distinction of different kinds of waste.
Here are some of the pictures of the kachra ghar located at Sarai Kale Khan
21-year-old Chootu who has been collecting waste from nearby areas of Sarai Kale Khan told NDTV that he has never heard about the system of waste segregation by FROM the authorities nor HAS he has been asked to collect the waste in a segregated form. He says,
Nothing as of now has been told to us, we have been collecting waste like this from starting. Whatever waste we collect from the area we come and drop in these dustbins.
We asked another waste collector if he has been asked to collect waste from the shelter homes situated nearby and he said,
No, the municipal corporation has only told us to collect waste from the colonies. Some of the people living in shelter homes come to the kachra ghars to dispose of their waste while many simply throw it in the backyard.
To get the civic body’s point of view, NDTV spoke with some of the officials from SDMC. One official said,
Waste management is a very new concept, we all are all trying to progress towards it in a stepwise format. We have first laid the foundation of the twin-bin system in place, now we are slowly moving towards awareness process which will help us achieve waste segregation at source.
Another official added,
Currently we are looking at managing housing societies waste only, we will soon draw out a plan which will also include waste management in shelter homes or neglected slum areas.
Experts’ View On Role Of Waste Segregation To Tackle India’s Garbage Crisis
Swati Sambhyal, programme manager at Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) says,
In New Delhi, nothing can be changed until unless there is a clear cut policy on waste disposal. The problem in Delhi is that there is no single authority responsible on the way we manage waste. It is very evident that waste segregation is not done well in the city.
Chitra Mukherjee, the Head of Programs for Chintan adds, “The problem in the city is inaction from the authorities. Everybody thinks the job will be done by someone else. No one is taking the responsibility or the ownership of handling the waste mess.
She further adds,
In slums or waste pockets management of waste is very easy, because one can find the waste managers within the society, moreover, waste generation compared to urban people is much less. But since the authorities ARE neither giving facilities nor doing anything, the waste management game is going down the drain in all these areas.
Fighting India’s Garbage Crisis
Fighting India's Garbage Crisis
- Challenges India Is Facing In Managing Its Waste
- Things To Know About Composting
- All About Upcycling And Recycling In India
- Rural Haryana Aims To Improve Its Waste Management, Here's How
- How Urban India Can Help In Effective Waste Management
- Delhi Is Not Segregating Its Waste, An On Ground Report
Fighting India’s Garbage Crisis is a special series by NDTV-Banega Swachh India team. As a part of the series, we want to highlight the basics of waste management system in India along with an on-ground report of the National Capital Region about the challenges it is facing when it comes to managing its waste effectively.
NDTV – Dettol Banega Swachh India campaign lends support to the Government of India’s Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM). Helmed by Campaign Ambassador Amitabh Bachchan, the campaign aims to spread awareness about hygiene and sanitation, the importance of building toilets and making India open defecation free (ODF) by October 2019, a target set by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, when he launched Swachh Bharat Abhiyan in 2014. Over the years, the campaign has widened its scope to cover issues like air pollution, waste management, plastic ban, manual scavenging and menstrual hygiene. The campaign has also focused extensively on marine pollution, clean Ganga Project and rejuvenation of Yamuna, two of India’s major river bodies.